Opinion: Is Record Store Day A Joke?
Does anyone remember that Morgan Freeman interview a few years ago? The one where they asked him about how he felt about World Black History Day and he replied “You want to confine my history to one day?” Obviously the music industry and its problems are a thousand miles away from the degradation that Black people have had to put up with for 400 years but I have a similar answer. You want to confine a section of an industry that is in deep trouble to one day?
In Leicester we have 3 choices in terms of where we can purchase our music. They are HMV, our SINGLE local record shop or the internet. I’ve been to our record store a few times and only purchased something once (Blink 182’s Neighbourhoods and that’s only because it came with a totally slamming poster.) On Record Store Day we’re all supposed to give up our bad habits, whether they be buying from the undercutting iTunes or illegal file sharing or borrowing from friends with a more extensive collection and head over to our local record store and purchase CD’s and/or Vinyl from them. If they’re involved in the day they might be selling limited edition Vinyl and CDs to encourage the event.
But then when I look at it, I don’t know why I don’t buy from my local record store. Rather than handing over my money to a massive corporation like HMV or buying songs from iTunes that are a locked file format so that you can only use the damn things on iPods, why don’t I buy the CD from my local record store so that the old music hippie behind the counter can continue to run his resilient store? It comes down to the two things that are causing the decline in the music industry. Price and choice. Like I’ve already said iTunes undercuts all others with £7.99 albums and HMV is always about £2-£3 cheaper than the record store. The other problem I have is the selection. Sometimes I go to HMV to see if I can get the latest hardcore CD and they don’t have it in stock, so I’ll go check the record store. I go to the punk section and I’m faced with EP’s and albums by punk bands that are blindingly obvious (Sex Pistols, The Clash) or bands I’ve never heard of who probably broke up before my existence.
My main point is this. It should be Record Store day, everyday – not just one day of the year. Record stores all over the world are closing down everyday, how can they be expected to give out free stuff or stock up on the special limited edition albums that bands have so whole-heartedly re-released for the occasion (at a not so generous price I’m sure). It’s not realistic and it just gives people who want to be a hipster the opportunity to tweet “Just went to my local record store and picked up the re-released Florence & The Machine Vinyl. #SupportRecordStores” before the next day they’re back on the Tumblr album leak page looking for the rumoured leaked Enter Shikari album. Music fans are the biggest hypocrites you will ever meet and World Record Store Day just allows them to parade that in full view.
Do you think Record Store Day is a good thing? Do you buy local or are you firmly with the internet like me? Leave a comment and we’ll get a discussion going.
April 20, 2012
I know the store you’re talking about and I can honestly say I don’t think I’ve ever bought a single thing from there, ever. However I have bought from many other independent record stores that are bigger and have way more choice! And better prices! But two of these stores have shut down in the past 3/4 years so they are obviously being squeezed by the internet.
I think World Record Store day is like Valentines Day. A token gesture for people who don’t really know or understand anything about love or music. Because if they did, they would support their store all year round and not just on one day to make themselves look or feel good. And also, independents should probably ask people what they want more of and try to provide it all year round if possible, not just cash in on special edition stuff that ‘fans’ might subsequently flog on eBay. However, it’s good that it exists to try to raise awareness about local record shops because the danger is that there’s an entire digital generation of kids growing up now that won’t even know about them…
Great article, like it 🙂
Report comment
April 20, 2012
I agree with the Valentines Day comment. Its a once a year thing that bands and hipsters go crazy for. The position of the shop in Leicester is rubbish. HMV’s on the High Street, and then this little independent is tucked away snugly in St Martins Square where no one knows of it. HMV just makes sense to most people.
Report comment
April 21, 2012
I agree but the thing is, rents for the main High Street where HMV is would be huge, which is why this shop is where it is. I think even HMV can’t afford to be there as they’re scraping by because of the internet now. But yes, St Martins is a weird location, as that’s where lots of upmarket bridal shops are. There used to be a great independent in the Arcade run by my friend’s dad but that shut down when you were in nappies I suspect ha 😛
Report comment